Winning Arguments with Myself
Have you ever replayed a conversation in your mind until you’re having an argument with someone who isn’t even in the room? I have.
By the time I actually see the person, they’re already three arguments behind. I’ve made my case, answered their objections, and delivered a closing statement that would impress a courtroom full of attorneys. They, meanwhile, have no idea we’ve been having a conversation. It’s exhausting winning arguments nobody else knows about.
And then there’s the phone. We can pick it up in a perfectly good mood, spend a few minutes scrolling, and put it down mad at somebody we didn’t even know existed five minutes earlier. We were getting along just fine without knowing them. Now we’re carrying their opinion around for the rest of the afternoon. How did we give a stranger permission to set the emotional temperature of our day?
Criticism Gets a Replay
I preached Sunday from Philippians 4:1–9 about the relationship between what occupies our minds and what comes out in our lives. As often happens when I’m preparing a sermon, I discovered I was preaching to myself before I ever got around to preaching to anybody else.
I tend to be a glass-half-empty kind of guy. I try not to be. But I can have a day with plenty of good in it and still spend the evening thinking about the one thing that went wrong. The kindness gets forgotten. The criticism gets a replay. Sometimes several.
We used to call that “stinkin’ thinkin’.” It’s a funny expression for something that can do real damage, especially when it settles into our relationships. Once I’m irritated with someone, everything they do can become more evidence against them. Something I would overlook in anybody else becomes another offense when they do it. Before long, I’m assigning motives I can’t possibly know and using words like “always” and “never.”
“You always do that.”
“You never listen.”
Those are heavy words to place on another person. They leave very little room for grace—or for an honest memory of the times that person did get it right.
Paul understood that life in the church includes strained relationships. In Philippians 4, he addresses a disagreement between two women who had worked alongside him in the gospel. He doesn’t tell us what the disagreement was about. That’s probably a mercy. Otherwise, we’d spend our time deciding which woman was right instead of considering whether we need to make a phone call ourselves. We can love Jesus and still need help getting along with people. I wish that weren’t quite so easy to prove…at least in my own life.
Dealing with What Troubles Us
But Paul also knows that we need somewhere to take what troubles us. Before he tells the Philippians what to think about, he tells them to bring their concerns to God in prayer, with thanksgiving. That’s a place to begin when our minds are busy rehearsing everything that’s wrong.
“Lord, I am angry.”
“Lord, I am worried.”
“Lord, I’ve had this conversation in my head six times, and I still don’t know how to have it with the actual person.”
We can pray honestly. Thanksgiving can be honest, too. We can name what hurts while remembering the ways God has been faithful. Both belong in the same prayer.
Paul promises that God’s peace will guard our hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. Then he calls us to give our attention to what is true, honorable, just, pure, lovely, admirable, excellent, and worthy of praise.
True–or Just Repeated?
True is a good place to start. Is what I’m repeating actually true, or does it simply fit what I already wanted to believe? Do I know why that person did what they did? Have I asked? Is there another explanation besides the one I’ve been rehearsing? Those questions might slow down a few conversations—and a few Facebook posts.
We also need to ask what we’ve stopped noticing. When we spend our days collecting evidence of everything wrong with the world, we can overlook the neighbor who quietly helps, the friend who keeps showing up, or the person who responds with kindness when harshness would have been easier. Those things are happening, too. They deserve some room in our minds.
Here’s a reminder we all need: we don’t choose every thought that enters our heads. Grief, anxiety, and painful memories don’t disappear because someone tells us to think better thoughts. An unwanted thought is not a failure of faith. Sometimes asking for help is the faithful next step.
Letting Go
But there are habits of attention we can begin to practice. We can notice when we’re rehearsing a grievance. We can pause before assuming the worst. We can bring a worry to God. We can tell someone about the good we see in them.
Paul tells the Philippians to put what they have learned into practice. That brings this whole matter down to something I can actually do today. I can put down the phone. I can stop preparing my next imaginary rebuttal long enough to listen. I can give thanks for something I would otherwise have overlooked. And perhaps, before I see that person again, I can let them catch up to the conversation.
Better yet, I can let go of the three arguments we never needed to have.
Until next time, keep looking up…
Discover more from Not the Perfect Pastor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
