Three Arguments Behind…

Winning Arguments with Myself

Have you ever replayed a conversation in your mind until you’re having an argument with someone who isn’t even in the room? I have.

By the time I actually see the person, they’re already three arguments behind. I’ve made my case, answered their objections, and delivered a closing statement that would impress a courtroom full of attorneys. They, meanwhile, have no idea we’ve been having a conversation. It’s exhausting winning arguments nobody else knows about.

And then there’s the phone. We can pick it up in a perfectly good mood, spend a few minutes scrolling, and put it down mad at somebody we didn’t even know existed five minutes earlier. We were getting along just fine without knowing them. Now we’re carrying their opinion around for the rest of the afternoon. How did we give a stranger permission to set the emotional temperature of our day?

Criticism Gets a Replay

I preached Sunday from Philippians 4:1–9 about the relationship between what occupies our minds and what comes out in our lives. As often happens when I’m preparing a sermon, I discovered I was preaching to myself before I ever got around to preaching to anybody else.

I tend to be a glass-half-empty kind of guy. I try not to be. But I can have a day with plenty of good in it and still spend the evening thinking about the one thing that went wrong. The kindness gets forgotten. The criticism gets a replay. Sometimes several.

We used to call that “stinkin’ thinkin’.” It’s a funny expression for something that can do real damage, especially when it settles into our relationships. Once I’m irritated with someone, everything they do can become more evidence against them. Something I would overlook in anybody else becomes another offense when they do it. Before long, I’m assigning motives I can’t possibly know and using words like “always” and “never.”

“You always do that.”

“You never listen.”

Those are heavy words to place on another person. They leave very little room for grace—or for an honest memory of the times that person did get it right.

Paul understood that life in the church includes strained relationships. In Philippians 4, he addresses a disagreement between two women who had worked alongside him in the gospel. He doesn’t tell us what the disagreement was about. That’s probably a mercy. Otherwise, we’d spend our time deciding which woman was right instead of considering whether we need to make a phone call ourselves. We can love Jesus and still need help getting along with people. I wish that weren’t quite so easy to prove…at least in my own life.

Dealing with What Troubles Us

But Paul also knows that we need somewhere to take what troubles us. Before he tells the Philippians what to think about, he tells them to bring their concerns to God in prayer, with thanksgiving. That’s a place to begin when our minds are busy rehearsing everything that’s wrong.

“Lord, I am angry.”

“Lord, I am worried.”

“Lord, I’ve had this conversation in my head six times, and I still don’t know how to have it with the actual person.”

We can pray honestly. Thanksgiving can be honest, too. We can name what hurts while remembering the ways God has been faithful. Both belong in the same prayer.

Paul promises that God’s peace will guard our hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. Then he calls us to give our attention to what is true, honorable, just, pure, lovely, admirable, excellent, and worthy of praise.

True–or Just Repeated?

True is a good place to start. Is what I’m repeating actually true, or does it simply fit what I already wanted to believe? Do I know why that person did what they did? Have I asked? Is there another explanation besides the one I’ve been rehearsing? Those questions might slow down a few conversations—and a few Facebook posts.

We also need to ask what we’ve stopped noticing. When we spend our days collecting evidence of everything wrong with the world, we can overlook the neighbor who quietly helps, the friend who keeps showing up, or the person who responds with kindness when harshness would have been easier. Those things are happening, too. They deserve some room in our minds.

Here’s a reminder we all need: we don’t choose every thought that enters our heads. Grief, anxiety, and painful memories don’t disappear because someone tells us to think better thoughts. An unwanted thought is not a failure of faith. Sometimes asking for help is the faithful next step.

Letting Go

But there are habits of attention we can begin to practice. We can notice when we’re rehearsing a grievance. We can pause before assuming the worst. We can bring a worry to God. We can tell someone about the good we see in them.

Paul tells the Philippians to put what they have learned into practice. That brings this whole matter down to something I can actually do today. I can put down the phone. I can stop preparing my next imaginary rebuttal long enough to listen. I can give thanks for something I would otherwise have overlooked. And perhaps, before I see that person again, I can let them catch up to the conversation.

Better yet, I can let go of the three arguments we never needed to have.

Until next time, keep looking up…

Covenant and the Cost of Leaving

I signed up for the covenant. That is where I need to begin this reflection. In my recent articles, I have asked, “Justice by whose definition?” The question behind this one is closely related: What do we mean when we speak of covenant, and what do we owe one another when we enter it?

Two recent posts from Facebook friends brought that question back to me. Both addressed the conflict involving Highland Park United Methodist Church and the Horizon Texas Conference. One emphasized the obligations clergy and congregations accept within a connectional church. The other questioned the consistency of leaders who invoke those obligations after departures from church law within their own ranks.

I understand the first argument. The second touched something that was central to my decision to leave The United Methodist Church in 2019.

The promises I made

I spent more than twenty-eight years as a United Methodist elder. I served congregations and served as a district superintendent. I understood that I belonged to a connectional church. I knew there were obligations that came with that relationship, and I had accepted them.

I also knew those obligations did not disappear every time I disagreed with a decision. A covenant that requires nothing of us when keeping it becomes difficult would be a pretty thin covenant.

Covenant in this sense is a biblical concept. God initiated numerous covenants throughout the Bible, culminating in the new covenant in the Gospel of Jesus Christ. The idea of covenant involves promises made before God, shared responsibilities and a commitment to seek one another’s good. Grace, truth, accountability and the work of reconciliation all belong to the covenant relationship.

Let me offer a word of clarity: a denominational covenant draws on biblical covenant, but it is not equivalent to God’s new covenant in Christ.

As the division within the denomination deepened, I struggled with my own place in it. I did not believe we could continue living faithfully as a divided people. I was angry with denominational leaders for failing, in my judgment, to lead in a way that reflected the covenant we had all agreed to uphold.

And I was troubled by my own faithfulness. There were aspects of my relationship with the denomination in which I felt I was falling short of the covenant I had accepted. That was on me. I did not want to be a covenant-breaker.

By 2019, I had reached a painful conclusion: I could no longer live faithfully within that covenant. Yet leaving felt like breaking it, too.

I was a delegate to the special General Conference in February of that year. Afterward, I knew I would leave, and I did so in August. That decision did not neatly settle the question of my faithfulness. I left carrying the weight of promises that still mattered to me.

When mutual accountability becomes doubtful

That history explains why one friend’s reflections resonated with me. He raised the question of whether the Book of Discipline functions as the law of the church or as a collection of requirements some people may choose to disregard.

I understand the force of that question. If we agree to live under a common Discipline, its authority cannot depend on whether we happen to agree with the provision before us.

Bishop Melvin Talbert’s actions were one example. He officiated at a same-sex union in 2013 despite the church’s prohibition. A complaint followed, and a “just resolution” was announced in 2015. He did not face a church trial or the possible loss of his credentials. There was a process. My question is whether that outcome demonstrated the accountability the covenant required.

Then came the election and consecration of Bishop Karen Oliveto in 2016. In 2017, the Judicial Council ruled that consecrating a bishop who was a “self-avowed practicing homosexual” violated church law. It also said she remained in good standing pending the appropriate administrative or judicial process. The ruling did not itself remove her from office.

My concern extended to every bishop who laid hands upon Karen Oliveto in that consecration. In my estimation, they, too, broke covenant and should have faced disciplinary scrutiny for participating in an action contrary to the church order they were entrusted to uphold.

What others celebrated as courage, I understood as a breach of our shared commitments. I could recognize the sincerity of their convictions and still ask why those convictions appeared to carry more weight than the promises we had made together. Who gets to have disobedience understood as an act of conscience, and who gets to have it treated as a failure of covenant?

For me, these events weakened confidence that our commitments were genuinely mutual. I was still examining whether I was keeping my promises while wondering whether the same seriousness was expected throughout the connection.

Another person’s unfaithfulness did not excuse my own. It did, however, affect whether I could trust the relationship we were asking one another to preserve.

The weight of questioning faithfulness

Another friend’s post emphasized the covenantal obligations of the Highland Park pastors. He says he does not presume to judge their character or private motivations. He also raises questions about their covenantal fidelity and whether their conduct warrants accountability.

Those are serious questions. Their conduct is not beyond examination, and I can’t resolve their faithfulness from the outside.

But I know what it feels like to wrestle with the possibility that leaving makes you a covenant-breaker. I know that departure can follow a painful examination of promises rather than an easy dismissal of them. When we question someone’s covenantal fidelity, we should leave room for that possibility.

My friend expressly acknowledges that accountability must apply throughout the connection. I agree. What I find missing is a fuller reckoning with the history that has made appeals to covenant difficult to trust.

Saying one has an obligation to a covenant doesn’t repair the trust damaged when people believe that obligation has been applied selectively. Saying that everyone is accountable should be followed by evidence that everyone is.

What covenant requires of us now

None of this automatically justifies Highland Park’s decisions. Nor does it mean that a violation of church law makes every other provision optional. That would leave us with no meaningful common commitments at all.

It means the church needs to examine more than the faithfulness of those who seek to leave. Those who exercise authority must also examine how their leadership has strengthened or weakened the trust on which covenantal life depends.

Too often, what I heard from leadership—whatever the intention—was, “Shut up and follow me!” That is how appeals to covenant sounded to me when questions about accountability went unanswered. What I needed to hear was a willingness to examine their own part in the breakdown of trust. An appeal to covenant would have carried a lot more weight had it been accompanied by an honest wrestling with questions like these:

What have we acknowledged? Where have we accepted responsibility? What have we done to repair relationships damaged by inconsistent accountability? How have we listened to people who believe they can no longer remain without compromising their own faithfulness?

Those questions belong alongside questions about clergy obligations and congregational responsibilities. They belong to all of us who have exercised leadership, myself included.

I can’t claim that I handled every part of my own struggle perfectly. I can say that the covenant mattered to me. That is why remaining became so difficult, and why leaving was painful. It is also why I entered a covenant with another denomination. I still believe in making promises before God and accepting the responsibilities that come with them.

That belief is also why I want the church to take the work of repairing trust as seriously as it takes the work of enforcing obligations. We need the humility to acknowledge where we have failed one another, the willingness to accept responsibility, and the grace to listen when someone says that staying has become a crisis of conscience. None of that makes our promises less important. It gives us a way to honor them even when the relationship is breaking.

I signed up for the covenant. It still means something, and because it means something, I believe we owe one another more than an accounting of who broke it. We owe one another an honest reckoning with what it would take to restore trust. We did not find a way to remain together. But those of us who left and those who remain still owe one another grace, humility, and kindness.

We no longer share a denomination. We still share the same name Methodist, and with it, more importantly, the call of Christ to love one another. May we all covenant to do so.

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.

Did Your Faith Survive Your Vote?

The election is over. Our call to faithfulness hasn’t changed. Many–and I mean many–political pundits have offered their commentary, and perusing Facebook, not a few pastors have offered their take, too. Well, I can’t resist. I’m going to add mine!

Before an election, it can be difficult to hear a pastor talk about faith and public life without trying to figure out which candidate he wants you to support. After this election, I want to ask a question: How are we going to live now?

There are Democrats and Republicans in the congregation I serve. We may have voted differently. We may feel differently about the results. But if our faith is in Jesus Christ, we are fellow citizens of heaven. We belong to him, and that belonging must shape how we treat one another.

As I prepare to preach from Philippians 3:15–21, I keep coming back to that connection between belonging and living. Paul tells believers where their citizenship is, but he also asks them to pay attention to how they walk.

That seems like a good word for the days after an election. 

Keep walking toward Christ

Paul has just acknowledged that he has not arrived. He wants to know Christ, and he is pressing on toward that goal. When he calls mature believers to share his way of thinking, he is calling them to that same humility and determination.

In verse 16, he calls us to live up to what we have already attained. We may not understand everything yet. We certainly have not become everything God intends us to become. But we can take the next step of obedience with what he has already shown us.

We know that Jesus calls us to love our neighbors. We know that he calls us to speak truthfully. We know that bitterness and contempt do not become holy simply because we think our cause is right. We don’t have to understand every political development to know those things.

Then Paul tells the Philippians to follow his example and pay attention to others who live according to the pattern he has given them. That raises a serious question: Whose example are we following?

Who is teaching us how to respond when we are disappointed? Who is shaping the way we speak about people with whom we disagree? When we are angry, whose voice do we reach for?

There are plenty of people willing to tell us whom to fear and whom to blame. We need more than a Facebook feed to teach us faithfulness. We need brothers and sisters who don’t always agree with us, but whose lives help us see how to follow Jesus.

And somebody is learning from us. They hear how we talk at home. They notice what we share online. They see whether our treatment of another person changes when we discover how that person voted.

Would following our example help them follow Jesus? 

Pay attention to what has your heart

In verses 18 and 19, Paul describes people whose lives make them enemies of the cross of Christ. Before we start assigning that description to people we oppose, we need to notice how he speaks: with tears.

Paul grieves over lives moving away from the cross. There is no pleasure here in finding someone to condemn.

This passage gives us reason to examine our own lives. What has my heart? What do I want so badly that I am willing to excuse almost anything to get it? Where have I allowed an earthly loyalty to determine what I will call good and what I will call evil?

We can become very skilled at recognizing the failures of people we oppose while explaining away the same failures in people we support. If we are going to follow Jesus faithfully, we have to let him examine that in us.

Christians should vote prayerfully and thoughtfully, with a conscience shaped by Scripture. We should seek the common good, defend human dignity, protect the vulnerable, and pursue justice. We will sometimes disagree about how to accomplish those things. That ought to send each of us back to prayer and an honest examination of our own convictions. Public decisions affect real people, and loving our neighbors includes taking those decisions seriously.

But we must not confuse political pragmatism with biblical obedience. Supporting a candidate does not require us to defend everything that candidate says or does. No party gets to take the place of Scripture in shaping our conscience. And no election result gets to take the place of Jesus in determining our hope.

We need to be honest about fear, too. Some people have real concerns about decisions that could affect their families and their futures. I have concerns of my own. Faithfulness does not require us to pretend those concerns do not exist. We bring them to Jesus.

The question is whether fear will govern us. Will it give us permission to hate? Will it persuade us to abandon what Jesus has taught us? Will we decide that obedience is something we can return to once our side is secure?

Faithfulness is needed right there, in the uncertainty. We can trust Christ enough to obey him before we know how everything will turn out. 

Remember where you belong

Paul’s language about citizenship would have meant something in Philippi, a Roman colony. Roman identity shaped its public life. Not everybody who lived there possessed Roman citizenship, but everyone lived in a community where that status carried significance. They understood that belonging somewhere could shape how you lived somewhere else.

I’ve been to Mexico numerous times on mission trips. When I’m there, I have to pay attention to the culture and communicate in a way the people can understand. I can’t expect everybody to do things the way we do them back home. But adapting to the culture doesn’t change my citizenship. I’m still an American.

At the same time, being an American doesn’t excuse me from caring about the people in Mexico. I went there to serve them. If I spend the whole trip reminding everybody where I’m from without learning how to love the people where I am, I’ve missed the purpose of the trip.

That helps me understand what Paul is saying. We belong to Christ, and we live among people he calls us to love. We need to understand their lives, listen to their concerns, and communicate the gospel in ways they can understand. We can do that without surrendering our allegiance to Jesus.

Belonging there gives direction to how we live here.

Our citizenship in heaven also shapes how we regard earthly authorities. In Romans 13, Paul addresses our responsibilities toward those who govern. But recognizing God’s sovereignty does not mean treating an election winner as God’s endorsed candidate. Winning does not establish God’s approval of a person’s character, policies, or conduct. We still pray. We still examine what leaders do. We still answer to Jesus.

And we should keep reading Romans 13. After speaking about governing authorities and paying what we owe, Paul speaks about our continuing obligation to love one another. That obligation remains after the votes are counted. The person who voted differently is still my neighbor. The vulnerable person who needs help still needs help. The person I have wounded with my words still deserves an apology. 

Take the next faithful step

Paul tells us whom we await: the Lord Jesus Christ, our Savior. Jesus is not returning to rescue a failed political strategy. He is returning to consummate his Kingdom.

In Philippians 3:21, Paul promises that Christ will transform our lowly bodies to be like his glorious body. That hope reaches into things an election can’t fix: our weakness, our mortality, and the grief of standing beside the grave of someone we love. Our Savior has not finished his work.

We do not have to make every political contest carry the weight of our eternal hope. We can participate responsibly in public life while remembering that our salvation rests in Jesus Christ. Elections, political parties, and candidates are temporary. The Kingdom of God is eternal.

So what does belonging there look like while we are living here?

It may mean putting down the phone before posting a comment intended to humiliate another person. It may mean praying for a leader you did not support, or telling the truth about a leader you did support. It may mean asking forgiveness from a family member or serving a neighbor without first asking whether that neighbor agrees with you.

At church this month, we are asking: What does my next step in knowing Christ look like this week?

That question belongs here, too. What has Jesus already shown me that I need to act on? Where is he calling me to surrender my pride, trust him with my fear, or love someone I have found difficult to love?

Whether your person won or lost, the next faithful step is obedience to him who calls us. Our call to faithfulness hasn’t changed because of an election.

We are citizens of heaven. Let’s act like we are.

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.

Justice by Whose Definition? There’s Only One Winner

The United Methodist Church is the gift that just keeps giving. Especially if you’re a Methodist pastor who writes a blog. I would much prefer the subject were something other than another church dispute, but here we are.

In recent posts, I’ve asked, “Justice by whose definition?” I’ve asked it about church property and about the treatment of pastors. Now, the conflict between Highland Park United Methodist Church and the Horizon Texas Conference brings me back to the question again.

Highland Park United Methodist Church in Dallas and the Horizon Texas Conference are embroiled in a dispute over church governance, denominational authority, and property. The conference sued after Highland Park changed governing documents in ways the conference says improperly removed denominational oversight; church leaders dispute those allegations.

In a recent called congregational vote, an overwhelming majority of those voting supported leaving the denomination, but the conference maintains that a congregational vote alone cannot end that relationship. The conflict now involves both a pending lawsuit and competing claims about who has authority to lead the church.

Hearing Both Sides

Let me begin by granting both sides something: I believe they think they are acting justly. Conference leaders understand themselves to be protecting a trust they have a responsibility to preserve. Highland Park’s leaders understand themselves to be acting faithfully on behalf of their congregation and its future. We can give both sides the benefit of the doubt about their intentions without concluding that either side has gotten everything right.

That is part of what makes this so difficult. People can sincerely believe they are doing the right thing and still need to examine what they are doing—and what it is costing everyone around them.

I bring my own history to this discussion. As many reading this know, I spent more than twenty-eight years as a United Methodist elder, including time as a district superintendent. I understand something of the responsibilities conference leaders carry. I also understand something of the frustration that leads people to conclude they can no longer remain in the denomination they once expected to serve for the rest of their lives.

So, I’m interested in the arguments about trust clauses, church authority, and property. But I keep coming back to a question that won’t be settled simply by determining whose legal argument is stronger. The question I’m wrestling with is this: What does justice require of people who claim to follow Jesus?

My Dog in the Hunt

Some may ask, “Do you even have a dog in this hunt?” It’s a fair question. I left the United Methodist Church in August 2019. I don’t have a claim on Highland Park’s property or a vote in the Horizon Texas Conference. Whatever happens in court, nobody will be sending me a check. I do, however, still have friends who serve it faithfully, and leaving did not erase my affection for the people or the institution that helped shape my ministry.

More than that, I’m still a Christian pastor. When Christians fight publicly, the damage to our witness doesn’t stop at the denominational boundary. People watching from the outside may not understand the difference between a United Methodist and an Evangelical Methodist, and most would not care to know. All they hear is Methodist. They hear us Methodists talk about Jesus, and then they watch how we treat one another.

That gives me a reason to care. It also gives all of us a question to consider: What are they learning about Jesus from watching us?

Already Defeated?

As I contemplate this situation, I can’t help but return to 1 Corinthians 6. Paul addresses a church in which believers are taking one another to court, and he has some uncomfortable things to say about it.

What troubles me most is that Paul doesn’t wait for a verdict before declaring that something has already gone terribly wrong. In verse 7, he tells them that having lawsuits against one another is already a defeat. Then he asks whether they would be willing to suffer wrong rather than continue the fight.

That is a difficult word to hear when we’re convinced we’re right. It is even more difficult when we believe we have a responsibility to protect something entrusted to us.

I can almost hear the objections because I’ve raised some of them myself. There are obligations to honor. There are gifts from generations of faithful people to protect. There are ministries to sustain and people whose future must be considered. Those responsibilities are real, and they deserve more than a dismissive wave of the hand. But Paul’s words deserve more than that, too.

If we can explain all the reasons we have to fight without seriously considering Paul’s challenge, have we allowed Scripture to examine our actions? Or have we simply decided that our circumstances are too complicated for it to apply?

I don’t read this passage as a blanket prohibition against every use of the courts. It should never become a way to silence victims or shield wrongdoing from accountability. Paul himself goes on to confront those who wrong and cheat their fellow believers. His concern includes both the injury being done and the way Christians are handling it.

Still, I can’t read this passage and come away comfortable with the prospect of Christians spending years and substantial ministry resources fighting one another over who gets to control the church.

At the very least, Paul calls us to examine what we are willing to surrender for the sake of faithfulness. That question belongs to everyone involved. It belongs to conference leaders charged with protecting the connection, and it belongs to congregational leaders seeking a different future.

Are we willing to accept an outcome that gives us less than everything we believe we deserve? Can we make room for the needs of the people across the table, including those who want to remain United Methodist? Can we pursue a settlement that allows ministry to continue without requiring one side to humiliate the other?

I don’t know everything that has been said behind closed doors or every effort that has been made toward an agreement. I do know that Paul gives us reason to keep pursuing one.

More Important Than Winning

Surely our responsibility to protect the church includes a responsibility to consider what our fighting is doing to it. That is why I keep wondering what a different outcome might look like. Whatever efforts have already been made, could both sides find a way to stay at the table long enough to reach an agreement without prolonging the litigation? And could both sides leave the negotiating table with something less than everything they want, yet preserve something more important than a victory?

A “just” agreement would have to take seriously the congregation’s future, the conference’s responsibilities, and the people who wish to remain United Methodist. Those people cannot become an afterthought. Neither can the ministry that might continue if the parties find a way forward.

I am not suggesting that any of this would be easy. I am asking whether the difficulty of reaching an agreement is greater than the damage of continuing the fight.

I bring that question out of my own experience. I was a delegate at the February 2019 special General Conference that adopted Paragraph 2553. When that conference ended, I knew my time in the UMC was coming to an end. I left that August, not for lack of conviction, but because I saw the fight that was on the horizon and I simply didn’t want to be a part of that fight.

Sometimes having the right to fight does not make fighting right.

And that brings me back to the question: Justice by whose definition? If our definition accounts for property, authority, and obligations but leaves no room for sacrifice, reconciliation, or love for the people across the table, we need to examine it again. We may be able to explain our position perfectly and still have trouble explaining how our conduct reflects Jesus.

Someone may eventually win in court. A judge-or judges-may settle questions of ownership and authority. But a favorable ruling won’t restore every broken relationship, recover every ministry dollar spent, or persuade our watching neighbors that we meant what we said about loving one another.

What do we lose while we wait to find out who wins? If we secure the property but damage our witness, if we defend the institution but deepen the division, what exactly have we protected?

The only winner in all this is the Devil. The Devil has been quite successful in sowing division among the people called Methodist.

Surely we don’t have to keep helping him.

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.

Guilt Might Be a Liar

Since Kobyn’s death, most mornings find me remembering him with a bottle of cologne. Our grandson sold cologne to work his way through college, and he once gave me a fragrance for my birthday. When I put it on in the morning, I think of him.

My morning routine includes me picking up the bottle of cologne, spraying it on and saying, “I love you, buddy, and I miss you. Wish I had been a better grandfather.” It’s that last sentence that gets me thinking.

The first two statements I know to be true. I love him. I miss him. But the third carries a judgment I’m not sure I’ve examined fairly. A better grandfather? Better than what?

Vanessa and I moved to Minden to be closer to our grandchildren. We wanted to participate in their lives. I try to attend their ball games and activities. I want them to know I love them. Still, I think about the things I haven’t done often enough. The fishing trips. The games we haven’t played. The conversations we haven’t had.

With Kobyn, those questions are especially painful. I wonder how things might have been different had I been more involved in his daily life. What if I had done something as simple as calling every day to say, “I love you, buddy”?

I wish I had made those calls. But wishing I had done something differently and knowing what difference it would have made are two different things. I can know the first. I cannot know the second. Grief doesn’t always know the difference.

Better Than What?

It doesn’t help that we carry around a pocket-sized collection of other people’s wonderful family moments. Open social media, and somebody is taking the grandchildren to Disney World. Another family is baking Christmas cookies in matching pajamas, while another grandfather appears to have made every ball game since the invention of baseball. Good for them. Really.

Those are good things, and the joy in those pictures may be entirely real. But I wonder what happens when I take the fishing trips from one family, the vacations from another, the traditions from a third, and combine them into my definition of a good grandfather. I’ve created a man who probably doesn’t exist. Then I feel guilty because I’m not him.

I can always find another picture to remind me of something I haven’t done. Meanwhile, I can overlook the relationship I actually have with a grandchild because I’m busy comparing it with the relationship I imagine someone else has. Seems a strange way to measure love.

Paul cautions against that kind of comparison in Galatians 6:4–5. He calls us to examine our own actions without comparing ourselves with someone else. That still leaves room for honest reflection about the grandfather I’ve been. But somebody else’s family pictures aren’t the standard by which I have to judge my love.

Yet comparison isn’t how I measure the love I have for my own grandparents.

The Grandfathers I Knew

Neither of my grandfathers would have fit that picture. Papaw Roberts was bedridden for many of the years I knew him. He didn’t come to ball games. He never took me hunting or fishing. During our teenage years, my brothers and I spent time helping him navigate life. That included some things that don’t make their way into sentimental social media posts about grandparents. You haven’t lived until you’re the one wiping your grandfather’s ass because he’s unable to wipe it himself.

Such was part of our life with him. There was nothing picturesque about it. He needed help, and we helped. When I remember Papaw Roberts, I don’t hold his inability to take me places against him. I loved him then and I still love him now. What do I remember most? His faith.

Paw Malone was always working. Six days a week, and he never thought another thing about it. It was his life. My joy was being with him at the store and working alongside him. We didn’t need to leave his daily life behind to have a relationship. I got to be part of it. He never took me hunting or fishing, never came to ball games, never sat down with me for card games or board games. Yet I don’t look back and think about how inadequate he was.

I loved him, too, and I still do. What do I remember most about him? His work ethic.

So why do I use the absence of those same activities as evidence against myself? Somehow, I can remember my grandparents with affection and an understanding of their circumstances, while remembering my own grandparenting with a running inventory of what I should have done better. That doesn’t seem quite fair. It certainly doesn’t seem like the whole truth.

Feelings Aren’t the Whole Story

I’m not trying to talk myself into believing every regret is misplaced. Time matters. Attention matters. Calls matter. We can fail people we love, and when there is something to acknowledge, apologize for, or change, we ought to do it. But there is a difference between acknowledging a missed opportunity and declaring an entire relationship a failure. There is also a difference between feeling guilty and being responsible for everything we wish had happened differently.

Our emotions are real. They deserve our attention. But they don’t know everything. My guilt can’t tell me with certainty how Kobyn experienced my love. It can’t tell me what a daily phone call would have changed. It can’t travel back through our lives and supply answers to every painful “what if.” It sure does like to keep asking the question, though.

And if I’m not careful, that question can make remembering Kobyn increasingly about evaluating me. Was I good enough? Did I do enough? How do I stop feeling this way? I don’t want my love for him to become only a trial of my own performance. His life was more than a measure of how well I did as his grandfather. Neither do I want to become so occupied with my feelings about yesterday that I fail to pay attention to the people in my life today.

The world doesn’t revolve around me or my emotions. My grandchildren have lives, joys, struggles, and needs of their own. They need me to be interested in those things, not constantly preoccupied with whether I deserve a passing grade. Maybe one needs a phone call. Maybe another needs someone to listen. Maybe there’s a ball game I can attend or an ordinary afternoon we can spend together. I can pay attention. I can ask. I can show up. And I can do those things because I love them, without asking them to relieve my guilt about the past.

What I Know Is True

Tomorrow morning, I’ll reach for the cologne again. I’ll remember Kobyn. I’ll love him. I’ll miss him. I’ll still wish I could pick up the phone and hear his voice. I will find myself saying, “Wish I had been a better grandfather.” I’m not going to pretend that writing about it makes the feeling disappear. But perhaps I can pause before accepting the verdict.

I can remember two grandfathers I loved deeply, whose lives with me looked very little like the pictures I sometimes use to judge myself. I can acknowledge things I wish I had done differently without allowing those things to become the whole story. I can let regret prompt me to love more attentively today without assuming it tells the whole truth about yesterday.

My love for Kobyn is real and the grief is, too.

But guilt? In this case, I hope it is just a liar.

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.

Forty-Five Years Together, Six Restaurants, and a Complaint About the Grits

Some people go on vacation for the scenery. Some go for the shopping. Apparently, I go for the food.

Actually, last week was our 45th anniversary. We had planned to celebrate it at Dauphin Island, AL with most of our family around, but a little thing called Hurricane Isias said, “Not so fast.”

We left home last Wednesday headed to Dauphin Island with Vanessa’s eye on the weather and me on my phone with the rental company. About an hour and a half into our trip we discovered that there was going to be an evacuation of the Island on Friday, and that the west end was already flooding.

You’ve heard the saying, “Come h**l or high water.” Well, it came high water! No beach for us. Isias messed up our plans and the plans for most of our children and grandchildren. Vanessa said, “Let’s go to Hot Springs.” 

I said, “Okay!” She took over driving and I got busy finding a place to stay. After driving 90 miles in the opposite direction, we turned around and headed north. We were packed for the beach but we were heading for the mountains. Talk about an interesting turn of events.

Vanessa and I just decided to eat our way through Hot Springs while celebrating our 45th anniversary. I thought I’d offer my completely unofficial restaurant reviews. Nobody paid me for these opinions. In fact, I paid pretty well for a few of them.

The Porterhouse — 5 out of 5

We started our trip at this nice steakhouse on Central Avenue, and it was an excellent way to begin. Great food, pleasant atmosphere, and a server who understood the difference between being attentive and constantly hovering over your shoulder.

Vanessa had the filet mignon, which will become relevant in a minute. Stay with me. There’s a steak comparison coming.

Superior Bathhouse Brewery — 3.5 out of 5

A brewery in a converted bathhouse is a pretty interesting idea. The food was typical bar fare. I had a bacon smash burger, and Vanessa had a sweet potato salad with fried chicken and a strawberry vinaigrette.

The food was good. Just not “Ooooo! Let’s go back there!” good.

Three things account for my rating. First, we were seated at a bar overlooking the city sidewalk, with our backs to everybody in the restaurant. Some folks might enjoy watching people walk by. I would have preferred a different seat.

Second, once the food arrived, our server wasn’t particularly attentive. We needed refills and ketchup. I finally got up and found the server to get more ketchup.

I know. It’s just ketchup. But when you need ketchup, you need ketchup.

Third, the food simply wasn’t memorable enough to make up for the other two things. Had we waited very long for a seat, I probably would have landed at a 3.

Luna Bella — 5 out of 5

ChatGPT told me this upscale Italian restaurant was the best in Hot Springs. I haven’t eaten at every restaurant in town, though I certainly made an effort, but Luna Bella made a strong case for itself.

The food was excellent. The service was excellent. They even brought us a complimentary chocolate mousse for our anniversary.

Vanessa had the fettuccine Alfredo. I’m not an Alfredo fan, but her dish was amazing. I had the eight-ounce filet mignon, ordered medium and cooked to perfection. It had the slightest char on the outside that formed the perfect crust.

Remember Vanessa’s filet at The Porterhouse? She tasted mine at Luna Bella and said it was better. That’s saying something, because The Porterhouse had already earned its five stars.

Be prepared to get off your pocketbook, though. Luna Bella is pricey. But for our anniversary dinner, we certainly enjoyed what we paid for.

Diablos Tacos and Mezcal – 4.5 out of 5

We couldn’t leave Hot Springs without planning a stop at The Grateful Head Pizza and Beer Garden.

I would have easily given it five stars because, well, the name alone ought to be worth something. LOL!

Unfortunately, they were closed for renovations. Seems as though the mountain shifted and ended up in their kitchen.

So, we ended up at a place on Central Avenue called Diablos. This was a first-time for us, but Mexican seems to be our default and we hadn’t had any for the week.

I ordered fajitas. It’s not often that fajitas melt in your mouth, but they use rib-eye instead of skirt steak. You pay a premium but they were probably the best fajitas I ever had.

Vanessa had something called Quesabirrias which is, according to their menu, a rib-eye prepared beef brisket style wrapped in corn tortillas that have been dipped in salsa and fried. Yes, I tasted. Slap yo’ Momma good!

So, why only 4.5 stars? I had to pay $4 for chips and salsa. Yeah, I know, but I’m a cheapskate, so sue me.

Put this one on your list. You won’t be sorry.

Now, lest you think we neglected the most important meal of the day…

The Pancake Shop — 4.5 out of 5

This Hot Springs landmark has been in business since 1940. We arrived at 8:10 a.m. and waited about 40 minutes for a table.

Was it worth the wait? Eh. Let me explain.

Nobody will ever accuse these folks of skimping on portions. I ordered three pancakes, a side of sausage, and a bowl of grits. Apparently, I thought I was feeding a small committee.

One pancake is the size of the plate. Stack two more on top, and you have to carve out the middle just to create a place to pour your syrup.

The sausage patties were huge, too. One pancake and one sausage patty would have been more than sufficient. I could not eat everything I ordered, though I gave it an honest effort.

The service was excellent, the price was incredible for the amount of food, and the fresh-squeezed orange juice was hard to beat.

So why the half-star deduction?

No matter how much salt I put on the grits, I couldn’t get them salty enough. And the syrup had a “wang” to it that I didn’t particularly care for.

That’s my highly technical culinary assessment. A wang.

If you skip the grits and like the syrup, you’ll probably give it five stars.

Colonial Pancake and Waffle House — 5 out of 5

Another Hot Springs staple, and this one checked all the boxes. Great food, great service, abundant portions, and a great price.

Sometimes there’s just not much else that needs to be said. Except, “Pass the syrup.”

There you have it. Six restaurants, two happy travelers, and a pretty good explanation for why my clothes fit differently after vacation.

Forty-five years together, and Vanessa is still willing to sit across the table from me while I explain what’s wrong with the grits. That woman deserves more than chocolate mousse. 

What’s your favorite place to eat in Hot Springs? We will definitely go back. Apparently, there are still a few restaurants we missed.

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.

Living a Life Worthy of the Gospel: Does Our Life Match Our Faith?

Philippians 1:27–30

At SpeeDee Oil Change, our technicians receive a shirt that says “Performance Certified” after they complete their training. The shirt tells the customer something: this person has been trained to do the work you are trusting us to do.

But the customer has a right to expect something beyond the shirt. He expects the right oil in the engine. He expects us to check what we say we will check and take care of the vehicle he has entrusted to us. The shirt makes a statement. The work ought to support it. If the shirt says one thing while the service says something else, which one do you think the customer will believe?

That raises a question for those of us who wear the name Christian: Does our conduct match the name we wear?

We can attend worship, carry a Bible, and know the words to the songs. But people encounter our faith in the way we speak to them, treat our families, conduct our business, and respond when things don’t go our way. What are they learning about Jesus from their experience with us?

We Belong to Christ

In Philippians 1, Paul writes from prison. His future is uncertain, but his reason for living is clear: to live is Christ. Then, in verse 27, he turns from his circumstances to the congregation’s responsibility. Whatever happens to him, they are to live in a manner worthy of the Gospel of Christ.

In his letter, Paul uses the language of citizenship, and that language helps us understand that calling. We have earthly responsibilities, with work to do and neighbors to love. But we belong to Jesus Christ, and our highest allegiance belongs to Him. When those allegiances come into conflict, Christ has the final word.

Now listen, we don’t earn that belonging by passing a performance test. The SpeeDee illustration can only take us so far. We belong to Christ because of His grace. He receives us, forgives us, and makes us His own. Then His grace begins to shape the way we live. Living worthy of the Gospel means living in a way that fits the grace we have received.

But, if we belong to heaven, how do we live here? Paul’s answer reaches beyond private behavior to the life we share.

Stand Together

We tend to make faith a very private matter. My relationship with Jesus. My spiritual growth. My preferences in worship. Each of us does need to respond personally to Christ. Nobody else can make that response for us. But responding to Jesus brings us into a people. We become brothers and sisters with responsibilities toward one another and a mission to share.

Paul wants these believers standing firm together and striving together for the faith of the Gospel. Their unity has a purpose beyond making church a pleasant place to spend Sunday morning.

Imagine a congregation encircling the sanctuary, holding hands in prayer. It is a beautiful image. People who have carried burdens all week stand with people who care. Someone who has felt alone discovers that somebody else knows their name and is praying for them. We need that. There are Sundays when just getting to church is an act of faith.

But what happens if we always face inward? The only people we see are the people already inside the circle. Our needs. Our concerns. Our preferences. Our traditions. Before long, our life together can become organized around keeping everyone inside comfortable.

Now imagine that same circle turning outward. We still stand together. We still pray for one another and carry one another’s burdens. But now we see the lonely neighbor, the family under pressure, the person who has given up on church, and the coworker who has never heard us say anything about Jesus. Our hands remain joined in mission and ministry, but our eyes are open to the people God loves.

Jesus withdrew to pray, then returned to the people. Our fellowship should strengthen our witness. Sometimes we’ve become so concerned about the world getting into the church that we’ve forgotten to get the church into the world.

When we think about our congregation’s future, do we picture only what would make life easier for those already here? Or do we picture the people we have yet to meet and the lives God might touch through us? We don’t have to wait until every question about the future is settled to love the neighbor God has already put in front of us.

Stand Courageously

Following Jesus will sometimes put us at odds with the expectations of people around us. That is a sobering thought because most of us want to be faithful and well liked at the same time. We would like to obey Jesus without creating an uncomfortable moment at the dinner table, in the break room, or among our friends. Sometimes that is possible. Sometimes it isn’t.

Acceptance must never be the condition of our obedience. If it is, eventually we will find something Jesus asks of us that we are unwilling to do.

Fear doesn’t always introduce itself as fear. Sometimes it comes dressed in reasonable language:

“I’m just trying to keep the peace.”

“I’m waiting for the right moment.”

“I don’t want anybody to think I’m being judgmental.”

There are times when waiting is wise. Sometimes we need to listen longer, pray more, or choose a different setting. But here is a question worth bringing before the Holy Spirit: Where have we renamed our fear?

Am I keeping the peace, or avoiding something I know I need to address? Am I waiting for the right moment, or have I decided no moment will ever be right? Am I being gracious, or going along with something that dishonors Christ because I want to fit in?

Courage may mean refusing a dishonest practice, even when it costs us a sale. It may mean speaking up when a conversation turns cruel, even when the people laughing are our friends. It may mean telling someone why our faith matters. And sometimes courage means admitting we were wrong.

“What I did was sinful. I hurt you. I need to ask your forgiveness.”

We can become very bold about everybody else’s failures while remaining strangely quiet about our own.

Courage does not excuse carelessness in the way we treat people. Sometimes truth will offend, even when spoken with love. But somebody’s offense does not automatically prove our faithfulness. We may need to examine our words, our attitude, or our motives. Our aim is faithfulness to Jesus. We speak truthfully, act lovingly, and accept that obedience may still meet resistance. God holds the outcome. We don’t have to win every argument or secure everybody’s approval. Courage is remaining faithful when faithfulness becomes costly.

Stand Faithfully

Paul tells the Philippians they have been granted the privilege of believing in Christ and also of suffering for Him. We understand why forgiveness and eternal life would be described as gifts. But suffering? Most of us would prefer to leave that part of the package unopened.

Paul is speaking specifically about suffering for Christ. Not every hardship is persecution. Some difficulties belong to ordinary life. Some are consequences of our choices. Sometimes people react badly because we have treated them badly. But obedience can carry a cost. An honest decision may cost money. A faithful conviction may cost acceptance. Open allegiance to Christ may strain a relationship.

Difficulty does not mean we have stepped outside God’s care. Faithful discipleship doesn’t mean an easy journey. Jesus called us to take up our cross and follow Him. That does not make pain pleasant or injustice acceptable. We can seek protection, ask for help, and work to correct what is wrong. But when we suffer for His sake, we share in His witness to the world. The One we follow knows rejection and suffering. He will not abandon us. Neither should His people abandon one another.

We need somebody who will pray when our courage wears thin. We need somebody who will remind us of what is true when discouragement starts doing the talking. We need a congregation that will help carry the cost of obedience.

If someone loses income because they refused to be dishonest, our encouragement may need to include practical help. If someone is rejected because of their faith, our fellowship needs to make room for their grief. If someone is exhausted from doing what is right, we need to come alongside them. Standing faithfully is something we help one another do.

Living Like We Belong

Perhaps you already know what faithfulness requires. The uncertainty is about what it will cost. I can’t promise obedience will make the problem disappear. But the cost of faithfulness does not put you beyond the reach of Christ’s grace.

This week, think of one person outside your usual circle whom you could notice, listen to, or serve. Think of one place where fear has been choosing your response. Think of one step of obedience you have delayed because it may be costly.

Bring that person, that fear, or that decision before the Lord. And if you are worn down from trying to remain faithful, let somebody stand with you.

The SpeeDee Performance Certified shirt makes a statement. The service ought to match the shirt.

We belong to Jesus Christ. Our service ought to match the Name we wear. We should live like we belong.

Where is God inviting you to take one faithful step this week?

Until next time, keep looking up…

The House Has a New Owner

Since my mom died, my brothers and I have faced a task that eventually comes to almost every family: cleaning out her house.

There is nothing particularly unusual about cleaning out a house. You open drawers. You empty closets. You decide what to keep, what to give away, what someone else in the family might want, and what simply needs to be thrown away. Except when it is your mother’s house, nothing is quite that simple.

A drawer isn’t just a drawer. You open it and find something you remember from childhood. A closet contains clothes you still picture her wearing. A cabinet holds something you haven’t seen in thirty years, and suddenly you aren’t standing in an empty house anymore. You’re ten years old again.

Cleaning out Mom’s house brought floods of memories. But it also brought another realization. Life can become incredibly cluttered without us ever noticing it.

Very few of us wake up one morning and decide, “I think I’ll fill every drawer, closet and cabinet in my house with things I may never use again.” It just happens.

We put something in a drawer because we might need it someday. We move something to a closet because we don’t know what else to do with it. We keep something because it belonged to somebody we loved. We hang on to something because throwing it away feels wasteful. One thing becomes ten things. Ten things become a closet full of things. Eventually we stop noticing.

It isn’t necessarily bad stuff. Some of it is valuable. Some of it is sentimental. Some of it once served an important purpose. But somewhere along the way, the house became cluttered.

As we worked through Mom’s house, another thought slowly began forming in my mind. This is what Jesus wants to do with my house. Not the house where Vanessa and I live. Me. My spiritual house.

The House Gets a New Owner

When we come to faith in Jesus Christ, something far more significant happens than inviting Jesus into our lives. The house—my house—gets a new Owner. We deed the property to him.

Paul puts it rather bluntly:

“You do not belong to yourself, for God bought you with a high price.”
—1 Corinthians 6:19–20 NLT

The deed has changed hands.

But here’s where things get interesting. We still live in the house. And living in a house you used to own after someone else has taken ownership can get uncomfortable. Because the new Owner begins opening drawers.

“What’s this?”

Oh, I’ve had that for years.

“Do you need it?”

Well, no. But I’ve always had it.

Then he opens a closet.

Jesus, we really don’t need to go in there.

But he does.

Opening the Drawers

There are resentments we’ve stored away. Old wounds we’ve carefully boxed up. Ambitions we haven’t quite surrendered. Habits we’ve learned to live with. Attitudes we’ve stopped questioning. Fears we’ve carried so long that we think they’re part of the house.

Some things aren’t necessarily sinful at all. They simply no longer belong in the life Jesus is creating. And some things carry memories. That’s when cleaning gets difficult. Because Jesus isn’t sorting through somebody else’s house. He’s sorting through mine. He starts rearranging furniture.

Wait a minute. That chair has always been there.

“I know.”

I like it there.

“I know.”

Then why are you moving it?

“Because this is my house now.”

And there, I think, is much of the uncomfortable work of sanctification. By grace, we gladly gave Jesus the house. We meant it when we did. But we didn’t necessarily understand everything that new ownership would mean.

We knew about the things lying around in plain sight. Those were often among the first things we expected Jesus to change. But then he starts opening drawers. Then closets. Then boxes we haven’t opened ourselves in years. And sometimes he points toward a door and we realize we’ve been living in this house so long that we had almost forgotten there was a room behind it.

“I’d like to go in there.”

There?

“Yes.”

Why?

“Because it’s mine.”

The Whole House is His

That may be one way of understanding what we Wesleyans have traditionally called entire sanctification. It does not mean Jesus has finished cleaning the house. It means there are no rooms we knowingly refuse to let him enter.

There comes a point when we stop following him from room to room negotiating over every drawer and simply say, “The whole house is yours.”

And that is more than another step in the cleaning process. It is a moment of surrender—a decisive work of grace in which I quit deciding which parts of the house Jesus may have. By grace, I hand him every key I know I possess. I may not yet know everything stored in every room, but there is no room I knowingly reserve for myself. The question is no longer, “How much of this house will I let Jesus change?” The answer has become, “All of it. Whatever you want. Wherever you want to go. The whole house is yours.”

Not just the living room where everybody can see. Not just the rooms I’ve already cleaned up. The closets. The drawers. The attic. The boxes. The room at the end of the hall. All of it. Yours.

Ownership and Renovation

That surrender can be real and decisive. But it doesn’t mean the work is finished. In fact, it may mean the real work has only begun. Because complete ownership is not the same thing as completed renovation.

Tomorrow Jesus may open another drawer. Next year he may move another piece of furniture. Ten years from now he may show me something that has been sitting in a corner my entire life, something I have walked past ten thousand times without ever realizing it didn’t belong there. That’s not evidence that I never gave him the house. It may be evidence that he loves me enough to keep working on it.

John Wesley understood sanctification as both something God does decisively and something in which we continue to grow. There is a genuine surrender of ourselves completely to God, but there is also a lifetime of discovering what that surrender means.

Maybe that’s because we don’t know our own houses nearly as well as we think we do. We know the rooms we use every day. Jesus knows what’s behind the walls. And grace keeps working. Opening. Sorting. Cleaning. Repairing. Rearranging. Sometimes throwing away. Sometimes uncovering something beautiful that had been buried beneath years of clutter. And all the while, we are still living in the house.

Trusting the New Owner

Maybe that’s one reason sanctification can be uncomfortable. The old owner still has opinions about where the furniture ought to go. I certainly do. But I’m learning that the question isn’t whether I like every change Jesus makes. The question is whether I trust the Owner.

After all, he didn’t purchase this house in order to destroy it. He bought it because he loves it. And he intends to make it into what it was always meant to be.

So perhaps the prayer of sanctification isn’t nearly as complicated as we sometimes make it: Jesus, this house belongs to you. Whatever you find, whatever needs to change, whatever room I have yet to discover—remind me whose house this is.

As my brothers and I worked our way through Mom’s house, every drawer we emptied and every closet we opened made the house a little less like the house we had always known. That was tough.

Those things were part of her life. Our life with her. Some brought laughter. Some brought tears. Some made us wonder why in the world she had kept them. And some were almost impossible to let go. But eventually, everything had to be examined.

Maybe that’s what I didn’t understand about sanctification for a long time. When I gave my life to Christ, I gave him the house. But I brought a lifetime of stuff with me.

Jesus keeps cleaning, sorting and rearranging, not because he despises the house, but because he loves the person who still lives there. And perhaps that’s the grace I’ve begun to see differently. Jesus didn’t buy the house so he could throw me out. He bought the house so that, room by room, it might become a place shaped by his presence.

So, when he opens the next drawer, perhaps I don’t need to become defensive. When he points toward the next closet, perhaps I don’t need to hide the key. And when he decides the furniture needs rearranging, perhaps I can trust that he sees something I don’t.

After all, the house isn’t mine anymore. I still live here, but thanks be to God, I don’t live here alone.

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.

Why I Am an Evangelical Methodist

People occasionally ask me why I am a member of the Evangelical Methodist Church, yet I pastor a Global Methodist congregation. It’s a fair question.

I spent more than twenty-eight years as a pastor in the United Methodist Church. I served churches large and small. I served for two years as a district superintendent. Methodism shaped me as a pastor and as a disciple, and I remain deeply grateful for many of the people and experiences that were part of those years. But today I am an ordained elder in the Evangelical Methodist Church. Why?

The answer begins with something very simple: They gave me a home when I didn’t have one.

When I Didn’t Have a Home

My introduction to the Evangelical Methodist Church came long before I ever imagined becoming part of it. In 1995, Rev. Dr. Fred Layman was one of my Supervised Ministry professors in seminary. Dr. Layman was a member of the Evangelical Methodist Church, and through him I learned for the first time that there even was such a thing as the EMC.

I wasn’t looking for another denomination. I was a United Methodist pastor and fully expected to remain one. The EMC was simply this little Methodist denomination that I learned about because one of my professors happened to be part of it. I certainly didn’t imagine that twenty-five years later it would become my denominational home.

In February 2019, I served as a delegate to the called General Conference session of the United Methodist Church. That experience became a significant turning point for me. After considerable prayer and discernment, I concluded that I could no longer remain in the denomination I had served for most of my adult life. By August, I had surrendered my United Methodist clergy credentials. What I didn’t have was somewhere else to go.

For almost a year, I was spiritually homeless. I still loved the Church. I still believed God had called me to ministry. I was still Methodist—Wesleyan down to my toes, as they say—but I no longer had a denominational home.

Then, in July 2020, the Evangelical Methodist Church gave me one. There is something powerful about being welcomed when you aren’t quite sure where you belong. The EMC received me, recognized my calling and ministry, and gave me a place to serve. I will always be grateful for that.

But gratitude alone doesn’t explain why I’m still here. Gratitude brought me through the door. Conviction is why I’m still here.

I Have Found a Theological Home

One of the things that increasingly attracts me to the EMC is its emphasis on Wesleyan holiness. In some ways, that attraction reaches all the way back to my childhood. I grew up next door to Pentecostal cousins, and occasionally I would attend worship with them. Those experiences made an impression on me. There was an expectancy about the work of the Holy Spirit that was different from much of what I experienced elsewhere. Then came the charismatic movement of the 1970s, right about the time I was coming of age. That movement reached even our little church in Chatham, LA.

So, from an early age I was exposed to Christians who believed there was more to the work of the Holy Spirit than simply getting us saved and getting us to heaven. They expected God to continue doing something in us. That stayed with me.

As I grew older and eventually entered ministry, however, I began to struggle with some elements of Pentecostal theology. In particular, I had difficulty with the emphasis on speaking in tongues as the evidence of a subsequent work of the Holy Spirit.

Wesleyan holiness theology eventually gave me another framework for understanding something that had attracted me for much of my life. The holiness tradition retains the expectation of a deeper work of grace. It has traditionally spoken of entire sanctification as a “second work of grace” or even a “second blessing.” But the emphasis isn’t on speaking in tongues. The emphasis is on holiness of heart and life.

God doesn’t merely want to forgive us. God wants to transform us. Grace isn’t finished with us when we are converted. The Holy Spirit continues working to make us more like Jesus. And there comes a place in the disciple’s journey where we are called to surrender ourselves fully to the sanctifying work of God.

I’m still working through exactly how I understand some of that language and how I understand it in my own experience. I can’t necessarily point to a particular date on the calendar and say, “There. That’s when it happened.” But I have become increasingly convinced that conversion cannot be the end of what God’s grace intends to accomplish in us.

One way I’ve come to think about sanctification is that when we come to Christ, the house gets a new Owner. Sanctification is the work of that new Owner opening closets, cleaning out drawers, rearranging furniture and sometimes showing us things we’ve kept around far too long. The goal isn’t merely that Jesus occupies a room in the house. The whole house belongs to him.

I find a theological home for that conviction in the Evangelical Methodist Church.

I Like Being Part of a Small Denomination

There is another reason I love the EMC that isn’t nearly as theological. It’s small. And I mean that as a compliment. Actually, there are only a few more congregations in the entirety of the United States than there were congregations in the district I served as District Superintendent in the UMC.

After spending most of my ministry in a large denomination, I’ve discovered something refreshing about being part of a denomination where it is possible to know one another.

I know our denominational leaders. They know me. They aren’t simply names printed beneath titles on an organizational chart. They’re people I can talk to, pray with, disagree with, eat with and call when I need something. There is something healthy about that kind of accessibility.

At our General Conference this summer, I was reminded again how much I value that. These aren’t distant denominational officials I know only by title. They’re brothers and sisters in ministry I actually know. Seriously, every congregation in the connection was represented. Every pastor was present. In all my years in the UMC, I never experienced anything like that.

Small doesn’t mean insignificant. And large certainly doesn’t mean bad. There are strengths and weaknesses that come with both. But at this stage of my life and ministry, I have discovered that I value relationships more than organizational machinery. I like knowing the people with whom I’m doing ministry. I like being known by them.

The EMC feels less like an institution I belong to and more like a family of churches and pastors with whom I share ministry. That matters to me.

I Like Simple

I also appreciate the relative simplicity of the EMC. I’ve spent enough years in church meetings to know that Methodists are capable of turning almost anything into a committee. And then appointing a subcommittee to study it. And then requiring a report from the subcommittee so the original committee can discuss it at the next meeting. Oh, and let’s not forget the potato salad—well actually, that part was good. But I don’t miss the endless meetings.

There is accountability in the EMC. There is structure. There are reports that have to be completed and meetings that need to happen. Any denomination needs those things. But the machinery doesn’t overwhelm the mission.

The paperwork is relatively simple and can be completed online in a matter of minutes. The denominational structure is relatively simple. There aren’t endless layers of meetings demanding the time and energy of pastors and congregations. I appreciate that more than I probably would have twenty years ago.

The older I get, the more convinced I become that the church’s structures should exist to support ministry rather than ministry existing to support the church’s structures.

I want to preach the gospel. I want to make disciples. I want to pastor people. I want to help people become more like Jesus. If our denominational machinery helps us do those things, wonderful. If maintaining the machinery begins consuming the energy we need to do those things, something has gotten out of order.

I’ve found the simplicity of the EMC refreshing.

Why I Have Stayed

There is one other part of the story worth mentioning. When I became part of the Evangelical Methodist Church in 2020, the Global Methodist Church did not yet exist. So, I didn’t choose the EMC over the GMC. There was no GMC to choose at the time.

Since the GMC was formed, however, I have been approached numerous times about becoming part of it. I’ve chosen to remain where I am.

That isn’t because I’m opposed to the Global Methodist Church. I’m not. I have friends there. I currently serve a congregation in the GMC. I want the GMC to succeed in its mission of making disciples of Jesus Christ and spreading scriptural holiness across the globe.

But somewhere along the way, something changed for me. The Evangelical Methodist Church stopped being simply the denomination that gave me somewhere to belong when I needed a home. It became my church.

Its Wesleyan holiness theology increasingly resonates with what I believe about the disciple’s life. Its size allows relationships that I have come to value deeply. Its leadership is accessible. Its structure is relatively simple. And its emphasis on holiness keeps calling me toward the kind of disciple—and pastor—I believe Jesus wants me to become.

I’m not suggesting the Evangelical Methodist Church is perfect. That would be a particularly strange claim coming from a guy who has a website called Not the Perfect Pastor. Every denomination has its weaknesses. Every denomination has things it needs to do better. The EMC is no exception. 

One example is our language around children and baptism. I remain uncomfortable with the option the EMC offers of dedicating children rather than baptizing them, because my understanding of Wesleyan sacramental theology leads me strongly toward infant baptism. 

That’s one place where I continue to wrestle with my own denomination. But I’ve reached a place in my life where I’m less interested in finding the perfect denomination than I am in being faithful where God has placed me.

Almost thirty years ago, Dr. Fred Layman introduced me to a little denomination I had never heard of. Twenty-five years later, that denomination welcomed me when I didn’t have a home. And over the years since, I’ve discovered something I couldn’t have known then: I wasn’t merely looking for somewhere to land. I was finding home.

Gratitude brought me through the door. Conviction is why I’m still here.

And that, my friends, is why I am an Evangelical Methodist.

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.

Have I Truly Surrendered to Christ?

Not long ago, I was listening to a preacher give an invitation at the end of a gospel concert. I don’t remember everything he said, but one question caught my attention: “Have you truly surrendered your life to Christ?”

It was a perfectly reasonable question. I’ve probably asked some version of it myself more times than I can count. But this time it confused me. What exactly does that mean?

Most of the people at a gospel concert are probably already Christians. Certainly, there could have been someone there who enjoyed the music but had never made a profession of faith. Perhaps someone needed to hear the gospel that night and respond to Christ for the first time. But I wondered whether there might be another possibility.

What if the person hearing that invitation had already surrendered his life to Christ? What if he had believed? What if she had been following Jesus for twenty years? What if the work Christ wanted to do in someone’s life that evening wasn’t the beginning of faith, but the continuation of it?

The question stayed with me because I realized I’m not always sure what we mean when we ask someone to “surrender your life to Christ.” There certainly is an initial surrender. There comes a moment when we recognize our need for Christ, repent of our sin, place our faith in him, and confess Jesus as Lord. As Wesleyans, we describe that as the moment of justifying grace. God forgives. God reconciles. God makes us his own.

But grace didn’t suddenly appear at that moment. God’s grace had already been at work. Wesleyans have traditionally called that prevenient grace—the grace that goes before. Long before we understood what God was doing, God was drawing us. Before we knew we needed grace, grace was already awakening us to our need.

In my old age, I have come to believe that we are never absent from God’s grace. We may not always be aware of God’s grace, but we are never absent from it. That doesn’t mean everyone is automatically saved. Grace can be resisted. We can turn away. We can refuse what God desires to do in us. But even our ability to recognize our need for God begins with God’s gracious activity toward us.

Then comes that moment when we say yes. We believe. We surrender. We trust Jesus. But what happens the next morning?

I Surrender All—Again

Since I was listening to a gospel concert, one of the old hymns of the church came to mind: I Surrender All.

I’ve sung it hundreds of times. And I mean it. I surrender all. Today. But tomorrow morning I’ve got to surrender it all again. That’s the part of surrender I don’t think we talk about enough.

Surrender isn’t simply something I did once. Surrender is a daily activity. I can sincerely surrender my life to Christ today and wake up tomorrow determined to have my own way about something. I can place my future in God’s hands and then spend the next three days worrying about it. I can surrender my anger and discover tomorrow that I’ve picked it back up. I can tell Christ that everything I have belongs to him and then become remarkably possessive when he puts his finger on something I don’t want to release.

Perhaps that’s part of sanctification. Yesterday I surrendered “all.” Today the Holy Spirit shows me something else that “all” includes. My ambition. My resentment. My money. My need to be right. My fear. My plans. My relationships. My pain. My reputation. My future. My sin. Apparently “all” is bigger than I realized.

That doesn’t necessarily mean yesterday’s surrender wasn’t genuine. It means God isn’t finished with me. That’s the difference between justification and sanctification. The grace that forgives me is also the grace that transforms me.

“Have You Truly Surrendered?”

That’s why I’ve become uncomfortable with that question—not because it is wrong, but because it can mean several different things.

“Have you truly surrendered your life to Christ?” Are you asking whether I’ve ever trusted Christ? Yes. Are you asking whether I’ve confessed Jesus Christ as Lord? Yes. Are you asking whether there was a moment when I believed and entrusted myself to him? Yes. But are you asking whether every part of my life is completely surrendered to Christ at this particular moment? Well…

Maybe I surrendered once. Maybe I didn’t this morning. I don’t think today’s failure necessarily invalidates yesterday’s faith.

Sometimes we Christian preachers collapse justification and sanctification into one event. We see someone struggling with sin, obedience, doubt, addiction, anger, pride, or surrender, and conclude that perhaps that person was never really saved. “You need to truly surrender your life to Christ.”

Maybe. Or, perhaps the person has trusted Christ and now needs to surrender to what the Holy Spirit is trying to do next. Perhaps this isn’t a question of whether justifying grace was real. Perhaps it is a question of whether I am presently yielding myself to sanctifying grace. That’s a very different question.

Can We Fall From Grace?

And this raises another difficult question. Can I fall from grace?

As a Wesleyan, I don’t believe in “once saved, always saved” in the way that phrase is commonly understood. I believe human beings remain capable of resisting God’s grace. Scripture takes seriously the possibility of turning away from faith.

But I wonder whether “falling from grace” is always the best way to picture what happens. A fall sounds accidental. I wasn’t paying attention. I stumbled. Suddenly I’m outside the grace of God.

I’m not convinced that’s a good description of our relationship with God.

Perhaps it is better to speak of turning from grace. I can resist the Spirit. I can ignore conviction. I can refuse obedience. I can repeatedly say no to what God is asking of me. And I suppose it is possible for repeated resistance eventually to become rejection. A person can turn away from faith. I don’t know that it requires someone to stand up one morning and formally announce, “I hereby renounce Jesus Christ.” Scripture’s warnings about drifting and hardened hearts suggest that turning away may sometimes happen gradually.

But neither do I believe that every act of disobedience means I’ve fallen out of salvation.

If it did, none of us could have assurance for very long. There is a difference between struggling within a relationship with Christ and abandoning the relationship altogether.

I can be disobedient and still be a disciple, though not necessarily a good one. I can resist the Spirit and still be someone the Spirit is pursuing. I can refuse to surrender something today without concluding that everything God has done in my life until today was imaginary. In fact, the conviction I feel over my resistance may itself be evidence that grace is still at work.

Grace Doesn’t Eliminate the Will

There is another distinction I think matters. Sometimes we talk about surrender as though everything depends upon human determination. Try harder. Do better. Make yourself surrender. Sanctification isn’t self-improvement with religious vocabulary.

At the same time, surrender isn’t passive. God doesn’t surrender my life for me. The Holy Spirit convicts. The Holy Spirit draws. The Holy Spirit enables. Grace makes obedience possible. But I still have to say yes.

Maybe surrender is best understood as the grace-enabled yielding of the human will to God. That’s different from willpower. Willpower says, “I am going to make myself a better person.” Grace says, “God is at work in me, and I am yielding myself to what God desires to do.”

Paul captures that tension beautifully in Philippians: “Work hard to show the results of your salvation, obeying God with deep reverence and fear. For God is working in you, giving you the desire and the power to do what pleases him.”

We work because God is working. We respond because grace has already acted. We surrender because the Spirit has enabled us to surrender. And tomorrow, we do it again.

Maybe That’s the Invitation

So, I’ve been thinking about that preacher’s question. “Have you truly surrendered your life to Christ?” Maybe the problem isn’t the question. Maybe we just need to understand how large the question really is. 

There is an invitation for the person who has never trusted Christ: Will you surrender your life to Jesus? Believe. Repent. Trust him. Receive the grace God has already been extending toward you.

But there is also an invitation for the person who has followed Jesus for fifty years: Will you surrender your life to Jesus? Not because your previous surrender was necessarily false. Not because every failure means you need to get saved again. But because Jesus is still Lord.

And there are still places within us where we would rather be lord.

Maybe the Christian life is learning, by grace, to surrender those places as the Spirit reveals them. Today it may be my pride. Tomorrow it may be my fear. Next year it may be something I cannot even see in myself today. That doesn’t mean grace has failed. It means grace is still working. Sanctifying grace keeps reaching into the places I haven’t surrendered yet and saying, “This too.” And I get to answer again, “Yes, Lord.”

The Goal Isn’t Becoming Better

Perhaps this is where I’ve finally landed. Christianity is often presented as though Jesus came to make us better people. I don’t think that’s quite right. Certainly, following Jesus ought to change the way we live. We should become more loving, more patient, more generous, more forgiving, more truthful, more compassionate. If decades of following Jesus leave us just as angry, selfish and cruel as we were when we began, something is wrong.

Becoming a better person isn’t the goal. We don’t follow Jesus to become better people. We follow Jesus to become like Jesus. Becoming better is the fruit, not the goal.

That’s why surrender matters. I can’t transform myself into the likeness of Christ by determination. I cannot grit my teeth and manufacture holiness. Sanctification isn’t a self-improvement project. It is the continuing work of God’s grace forming Christ in me.

My part is surrender. Not once. Again. And again. And again.

There was a day when I surrendered my life to Christ. I meant it. By God’s grace, I still mean it. But this morning there are things I need to surrender again. And tomorrow morning, if God gives me another day, I suspect there will be more. That’s not evidence that my surrender failed. Maybe that’s simply what a life of surrender looks like.

So, what about you? Have you surrendered your life to Jesus Christ?

Until next time, keep looking up…

If any of my reflections encouraged or challenged you, follow Not the Perfect Pastor on Facebook for more conversations about faith, ministry, and becoming faithful disciples of Jesus.